A map on page 71 of Unit 3 in the chapter "The Rise of the Marathas" in the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) Social Science textbook for Class 8, has ignited controversy by depicting Jaisalmer as part of the Maratha Empire.
This portrayal has drawn sharp criticism from a member of the erstwhile Jaisalmer royal family, and triggered significant online outrage on Tuesday, with demands to halt the alleged distortion of history, according to a New Indian Express report.
Chaitanya Raj Singh Bhati, a member of the erstwhile royal family of Jaisalmer, voiced strong objections on X on Monday, August 5, stating, “The depiction of Jaisalmer as a part of the then Maratha Empire is historically misleading, factually baseless and deeply objectionable.”
He further alleged, “Such unverified and historically unsubstantiated information not only raises questions about the credibility of institutions like NCERT but also hurts our glorious history and public sentiments. This issue is not merely a textbook error but appears to be an attempt to tarnish the sacrifices, sovereignty, and valorous saga of our ancestors.”
Plea to the education minister
Bhati urged Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan to address the issue urgently, stating, “This is not just a matter of factual correction but is connected to our historical dignity, self-respect, and the integrity of the national curriculum. Prompt and concrete action is expected on this matter.”
Reactions
The controversy has resonated widely online. History enthusiast @Ajatashatru expressed dismay on X, saying, “Absolutely appalling to see NCERT peddling such a historically inaccurate and deeply disrespectful narrative to please political masters. To portray Jaisalmer as part of the Maratha Empire is not just factually wrong. It’s an erasure of Rajput sovereignty and sacrifice.”
Official response
NCERT has declined to comment on the issue, and the Education Ministry has not yet responded to queries. However, a source informed TNIE, “We have asked NCERT to respond to the allegations made against them. It will be shared with the media when it is made public.”
